Here’s a holiday PSA for you—just because you got the perfect gift doesn’t mean your gifting game should stop there. A gorgeous candle or the perfect fashion accessory just looks lame when stuffed in a drugstore bag with some sad tissue paper surrounding it.
And besides, you can only argue that tacky SpongeBob SquarePants wrapping paper from CVS is ironic for so long.
Even if you’re not a paper snob, there are plenty of great prints, patterns, and paper types to be had in all corners of the internet, thanks to places like Etsy, Darby Smart, and our own personal favorites, Revel & Co. and Rifle Paper Company.
To help you pick out the perfect paper, we’ve rounded up 15 styles. Happy gifting!