I Tested Out 22 Pink Lipsticks in a Week, and These Are Officially My Favorites

I Tested Out 22 Pink Lipsticks in a Week, and These Are Officially My Favorites
Photo: Courtesy of Casey Clark; Adobe. Design: Cierra Miller/STYLECASTER.

Scroll To See More Images

Anyone who knows me can attest to the fact that I love the color pink. There isn’t a day that goes by where I’m not wearing pink eyeshadow, pink glitter, or pink lipstick (and sometimes all three!). Yes — I’m really living my own Barbie dreams thanks to pink makeup. When it comes to the shade of pink, I’m not too picky — frankly, I love it all. It can be bubblegum pink, hot pink, baby pink, pastel pink, or anything in between. After all, at the end of the day pink is pink.

I don’t mean to fall into the outdated cliche that “pink is for girls,” but I’m definitely a girl who adores the color pink. Whether it comes to makeup or my outfit, I wear pink lipstick because it makes me feel pretty, bold, and, well, beautiful. Regardless of whatever makeup trends are currently going viral, I almost always favor my pink hues. I mean, makeup shouldn’t be worn for others, but for themselves. End of rant.

As a self-professed pink lipstick connoisseur, here’s what I look for: vibrancy and color, ease of application, and coverage. Also, while I do I think about how the shade looks against my skin tone, if I like the color itself, I’ll usually overlook that. With that said, I went through 22 pink lipsticks from some of my favorite beauty brands and put them up against each other to see which ones will have a permanent home in my makeup bag. Read on to see what the best pink lipsticks are and where you can get your hands on them ASAP.

Our mission at STYLECASTER is to bring style to the people, and we only feature products we think you’ll love as much as we do. Please note that if you purchase something by clicking on a link within this story, we may receive a small commission of the sale.  

STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

MAC Cosmetics in Candy Yum

My go-to pink lipstick has to be Candy Yum-Yum. Its creamy formula glides right on the lips in just one swipe for a highly pigmented super-bright bubblegum pink color. This lipstick claims to have a “no-shine matte finish,” but it’s more semi-matte. It’s not super drying and unfortunately is not transfer-proof so there’s no escaping the dreaded smudge — but it’s still a must-have in my book. Sadly, this shade is going to be discontinued, so if you want to get your hands on a tube, act fast!


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Dose of Colors in Pinky Promise

I ~pinky~ promise you that you’ll love this lipstick just as much as I do. It’s less of a bubblegum color compared to Candy Yum Yum, and more of a hot pink with fuchsia undertones. The comfortable formula is quite thick so a little goes a long way when it comes to application. In about 30 seconds or so, watch your lips quickly dry to a velvet matte finish that will last for a large portion of the day (and won’t dry out your lips!).


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Kat Von D.

Kat Von D Studded Kiss in Backstage Bambi

Pink lipstick is amazing overall, but, I’m not going to lie, amazing packaging never fails to get my attention. KVD’s lipsticks come in fun, creative packaging — think early 2000’s pop-punk. Backstage Bambi is a similar color to Candy Yum-Yum — a bright bubblegum pink that falls on the cooler end of the spectrum. Best of all, it doesn’t settle into the cracks and crevices on your lips, unlike other matte lipsticks.


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

ColourPop Creme Lipstick in Fizzy Pop

ColourPop is one of my absolute favorite brands. Unfortunately, my favorite pink shade of all time, Are You Surreal, is discontinued (sad face), but Fizzy Pop is a close second. This shade is a hybrid of hot and baby pink. It’s natural-looking but has enough pigment to stand out. Similar to the brand’s other Lippie Stixs, this pink shade glides on nicely and its precise application calls for even lines, which are crucial when wearing pink lipstick. 


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Huda Beauty Power Bullet Matte Lipstick in Bachelorette

If you’re looking for an extremely full-coverage and ultra-pigmented lipstick, this is it. Bachelorette is a gorgeous long-wearing Fuschia shade that serves some serious color payoff. This cool-toned lipstick glides on seamlessly and doesn’t settle at all for a picture-perfect look. Oh, and It’s also cruelty-free so you can feel good about wearing it. 


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Smashbox Be Legendary Lipstick in Poolside

I absolutely love this cool-toned pink lipstick. Not only does it go on creamy in just one swipe, but it’s infused with peptides to create the appearance of soft and supple lips. Its precise tip makes it easy to apply and line the lips while getting into those inner corners that often go missed. Plus, it gives a satin finish that leaves a subtle shine for a fuller-looking pout.


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Makeup For Ever Lipstick in Fierce Flamingo

If I absolutely ~had~ to narrow it down, this formula would probably be my second go-to pink lipstick because it’s a super vibrant and long-wearing. It delivers a seamless, one swipe coverage and a creamy formula that allows for easy application. Plus, it gets extra credit points for not sucking every ounce of moisture from my lips and the sleek black packaging gives it a luxurious look that’ll make you feel like a million bucks.


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Ilia Color Block High Impact Lipstick in Knockout

This vegan pick lipstick is more sheer and glossy looking than some of the others I tested out, but it’s extremely pretty nonetheless. For those who want to achieve a subdued pink lip, this shade isn’t super loud, but it’s still highly pigmented. This lipstick applies super smoothly and creates a full coverage look with just one swipe.


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Morphe Cream Lipstick in Loudmouth

With a price tag of just $5, you can’t go wrong with this hot pink lipstick. Its smooth and creamy formula glides right on the lips and leaves a demi-glossy finish. While not transfer-proof, carry it around in your purse to touch up throughout the day and you’re all set.


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

CTZN Cosmetics Lipstick in Los Angeles

Looking for more of a nude-pink lipstick? CTZN Cosmetics has you covered with this dark mauve shade. The lipstick has a creamy, velvety texture from its infused wild mango butter that coats the lips with moisture and provides opaque coverage. Best of all — there’s no transfer so you can eat, drink, and kiss without worry. Want more of a shine? Use the lip gloss on the other side. 


STYLECASTER | Best Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

NYX Extra Creamy Round Lipstick in Hot Pink

NYX Cosmetics is a premium drugstore brand that offers some of the best lipsticks on the market, including this dark pink hue. For the ultimate transfer-proof lipstick, this is your go-to. It glides on creamy, but dries to a waxy or sticky finish. That might not sound pleasant, but after a few seconds your lips will quickly adjust and you won’t have to reapply for the entire day, seriously. Plus, with a price tag of $6, you’ll get the most for your money with enough product that will last you a long time. 


Casey mary kay lipstick I Tested Out 22 Pink Lipsticks in a Week, and These Are Officially My Favorites

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Powerful Pink

Formulated with gel microsphere technology, this bright pink lipstick offers full coverage in one swipe and long lasting wear. The lightweight formula glides and dries in seconds. For added oomph, this lipstick has a soft-focus effect to scatter light and minimize the appearance of texture and cracks. 


STYLECASTER | Best Pink LIpsticks

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Urban Decay Vice Lipstick in Hollyweird

Urban Decay’s brand new Vice pink lipstick in the hue Hollyweird is my definition of “pink perfection.” With a creamy, smooth formula, this lipstick glides right on and provides highly pigmented color. Plus, it’s both vegan and cruelty-free so you can feel good about what’s on your lips. While not fully transfer-proof, this lipstick is long-wearing and lasts a long time. 


STYLECASTER | Pink Lipsticks

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

Smashbox Lipstick in Poolside

Smashbox’s Be Legendary plush lipstick offers a creamy and smooth formula that thoroughly coats the lips. It’s a little more on the glossy side as opposed to matte so it’s not transfer-proof, but it does dry down quite a bit. The lipstick is also infused with a primer and ceramides built-in to help hydrate lips while keeping them looking plump.


STYLECASTER | Pink LIpstick

Courtesy of Casey Clark.

The Lipbar Lipstick in Playmate

In elegant black packaging, find a dark pink lipstick that provides a super-precise application with its pointed doe foot. It goes on creamy and dries super matte so it feels comfortable.

A Few Honorable Mentions

While I don’t have pictures wearing these shades, I’ve tried these pink lipsticks before and they are some of my absolute favorites as well! 

STYLECASTER | Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Kevyn Aucoin.

Kevin Aucoin Unforgettable Lipstick in Enigma

This lightweight lipstick boasts a vibrant pink color in a single swipe. With a glossy finish, enjoy the benefits of a highly pigmented matte lipstick without the drying effects. Plus, it looks amazing with different complexions. 


STYLECASTER | Pink Lipsticks

Courtesy of Elf.

Elf Cosmetics Seriously Satin Lipstick in Taffy

This light pink, rouge lipstick gives your lips a shiny, satin finish with its creamy formula. Infused with jojoba oil, macadamia seed oil and meadowfoam seed oil nourish, moisturize and soothe dry lips. 

 

 

STYLECASTER | Pink Lipsticks

Courtesy of W3ll People.

W3ll People Lipstick in Om Yeah

Formulated with organic shea butter, silk and jojoba oil, add a light pink color to your lips while hydrating and nourishing simultaneously. Boasting more of a natural pink, this lipstick can serve as a nude for those “no makeup” makeup looks. 


Bodyography I Tested Out 22 Pink Lipsticks in a Week, and These Are Officially My Favorites

Courtesy of Bodyography.

Bodyography Lava Liquid Lipstick in Candy

This cruelty-free and vegan hot lipstick goes on smooth and dries instantly without sucking every ounce of moisture from your lips. Its micro-absorb technology ensures lipstick stays on your lips all day long so you don’t have to keep reapplying. Plus, with a soft metallic finish, your lips will stand out with any look making this a must-have shade. 


STYLECASTER | Pink Lipstick

Courtesy of Trinny.

Trinny London Lip Lux Lip Color in Pookie

For natural-looking lips with a hint of color, Trinny London’s Lip Luxe is the way to go. Classified as bright, this pink shade goes on smooth and is super buildable so you can achieve the desired shade. Apply with the tip of your finger for quick and easy coverage you can count on. 

JH Poutspoken LiquidLip Momma Open PDP x1024@2x I Tested Out 22 Pink Lipsticks in a Week, and These Are Officially My Favorites

Jaclyn Cosmetics Poutspoken Liquid Lipstick in Momma

This classic pink shade is destined to be a staple in your makeup bag. Formulated with synthetic beeswax, Vitamin A, Vitamin E and avocado oil, this lipstick hydrates and nourishes lips for a soft, smooth feel. For a final touch, this lipstick has a light cake batter fragrance that you’ll love. 


STYLECASTER | Pink Lipsticks

Courtesy of Jason Wu.

Jason Wu Honey Fluff Lip Cream in Wu Me

This clean pink lipstick is infused with grape seed oil and jojoba oil designed to keep your lips looking and feeling soft and smooth. Its whipped formula goes on smoothly and creates a lightweight finish that’s nearly impossible to feel. Plus, it can be used as a blush on the cheeks so it’s a 2-1 deal. 

STYLECASTER | Ashley Benson Interview

share