Molten Metallic Eyeshadows That Are Total Show-Stoppers

Alicia Kort
Molten Metallic Eyeshadows That Are Total Show-Stoppers
Photo: Courtesy of Anastasia/Adobe.

If you want a super natural look, you don’t reach for metallic eyeshadows. But if you want to turn heads or post a smoldering selfie, you reach for your bronze, gold, brown and gray eyeshadow palettes. As a species, we are drawn, much like Magpies, to shiny and glittery objects. When you scroll down and see the shimmery palettes we’ve selected, it might be hard to resist. Your eyes just lap up those decadent colors. We associate metallics with wealth and glamour, so why wouldn’t you want to wear that on your lids? You can transform into a Hollywood-inspired glamazon or look like you’ve been through a futuristic post-apocalyptic battle—in a cool way—with an intense smokey eye while rocking all black. Wearing metallic shadows can also give you a bit of an edgy look. 

When searching for the perfect metallic shadow, it should be long-lasting and all of the shades should be highly pigmented. High pigment means that the colors are more concentrated, so you have a stronger, more saturated eyeshadow. You won’t have to swipe on 10 layers for your eyeshadow to be noticeable. You should just need one, two or maybe three, depending on how intense you want your look to be, and be ready to go. We found the best metallic eyeshadows that are highly pigmented and come in a wide range of colors, from your signature gray to a metallic green. Check out our options below.

STYLECASTER’s mantra is ‘Style To The People’— and our mission is to be an accessible, inclusive, ahead-of-the-trend destination for millennial and Gen Z women who want to live with style and substance. Our fashion, beauty and lifestyle coverage is equal parts informative and inspiring, and at once aspirational yet attainable. If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, we may receive an affiliate commission.

1. Stila Magnificent Metals Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

Stila Magnificent Metals Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

Courtesy of Stila.

This metallic eyeshadow was made for turning heads. It combines a rich pearly shade with glitter, so you get that extra glam rock pop without having to add on an extra layer of glitter. Because it’s liquid rather than a creamy powder, this shadow is made to last all night long. It dries quickly and is lightweight. There are nine stunning shadow shades to browse.



Courtesy of Haus Laboratories.

This highly pigmented liquid eyeshadow comes in super cool shades, ranging from Chained Ballerina to Aphrodite. It claims to be fallout free, which is rare when you’re applying shimmer to your eyelids. This blendable formula transforms into a powder on your eyelids, so you can shine bright all day and night long without worrying about constantly reapplying.

3. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Cosmic Metals Eyeshadow Palette

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Cosmic Metals Eyeshadow Palette

Courtesy of NYX.

Instead of your usual silvers and blacks, NYX goes to space to find these otherworldly metallic shades. These highly pigmented, creamy shadows range from pink to mauve, which will help you create a neutral or show-stopping look. These shadows can be worn every single day and for a variety of occasions. You get six shades in this palette.

4. Mallofusa 5 Colors Eye Shadow Palette


Mallofusa 5 Colors Eye Shadow Palette

Courtesy of Mallofusa.

These shimmery shades are oil-free and non-irritating, so you’ll get all of the glimmer and none of the itchiness. The baked metallic eyeshadow palette, featuring bronzes and golds, has pearlescent shades that go on light and smooth. These highly pigmented shades will give you that intense, show-stopping look that you want. The Mallofusa eyeshadow claims to last up to eight hours and won’t fade.

5. Profusion Cosmetics Metallics Eyeshadow Palette


Profusion Cosmetics Metallics Eyeshadow Palette

Courtesy of Profusion Cosmetics.

All of the eyeshadows in this 24 shadow palette both shine and shimmer. From the rich brown Mic Drop to the shimmery green Geode, you’ll have a cornucopia of shades to play with in this cruelty-free palette. These shades are high-pigment and easily blend-able with your favorite matte shades. You can wear one of these shades solo, layer them on top of each other for the ultimate metallic look or combine them with other eyeshadows.