There are few things more satisfying than removing your makeup at the end of the day—it’s basically the skin-care equivalent of peeling off your stomach-squeezing tights and shedding your bra as soon as you get home from work. But if you’re following a green beauty routine, your natural, gentle makeup remover may be more of a makeup smudger-arounder, leaving you with pore-clogging residue that your cleansers can’t wash off.
But that doesn’t mean you need to ditch your routine and pick up a remover with fifty-three unpronounceable ingredients—you just need to find the right one. And that’s where we come in. We rounded up the seven best natural makeup remover wipes, pads, and solutions that actually dissolve every last speck of makeup all without cooking your face in a stew of chemicals. Keep reading to see our favorites, then try them out for yourself.